A Florida appeals court handed down a ruling this fall that anyone who has used a sperm donor, egg donor, or surrogate in this state should read twice. The case came out of a Miami Dade probate court, but the lesson reaches into family law statewide. A signed donor agreement controls parental rights, and a will cannot quietly undo it after the fact.
The dispute
Malcolm Dorman died in March 2021 owning several homes, including a house on Ocean Boulevard in Golden Beach. Years before his death, he and Melissa Azrack signed a sperm donor agreement. The agreement said Azrack would be the only intended parent of any child born from it and that Dorman gave up whatever parental rights he might otherwise have had. Azrack gave birth to a daughter in 2017.
Dorman never treated the agreement as the end of the story. His will called the child his daughter, left her specific property, and named her as a beneficiary of a trust. After he died, Azrack went to probate court seeking to have the Golden Beach property declared Dorman’s homestead so the child could inherit it.
The estate’s personal representative opposed her on two separate grounds. First, he argued Dorman was never the child’s legal or biological parent, because the donor agreement had already settled that question and Azrack had not proven otherwise. Second, he argued the Golden Beach property was not protected homestead at all, so even a proven child of Dorman’s would get nothing from it.
The trial court agreed with the estate on both points. Azrack appealed, but she only challenged the paternity finding. She left the homestead ruling alone.
Why the appeal failed
The Third District Court of Appeal did not need to decide whether Dorman was the child’s biological or legal father. Florida law has a simple rule for cases like this. When a judgment rests on two independent grounds and the appeal only attacks one of them, the untouched ground stands on its own and the judgment gets affirmed no matter who was right on the other issue. That is exactly what happened here. The court called the result fatal to the appeal, not because the paternity argument necessarily failed on the merits, but because Azrack never gave the court a reason to overturn the homestead ruling that made the paternity question beside the point.
The court also threw out a separate appeal of post judgment motions. It held that a motion to vacate under the ordinary civil rules does not apply in a probate case unless the proceeding was formally declared adversary. This one was not. The court also rejected the argument that the judgment improperly bound Azrack personally, since she had put herself into the case by seeking to validate the donor agreement she had signed.
What Florida law actually says about donor agreements
Florida Statute 742.14 governs this directly. A person who donates eggs, sperm, or preembryos gives up all maternal or paternal rights and obligations toward any child that results, with one exception. A commissioning couple who are the intended parents keep their rights under the agreement. The statute does not care what a will says years later. It looks at what the parties signed when the donation happened.
That is the real lesson for anyone building a family through assisted reproduction in Florida. A donor who later wants to claim parental rights, or an intended parent who later wants to deny them, is fighting an agreement the law already resolved at the time of signing. Changing your mind afterward, in a will or anywhere else, does not rewrite the contract.
This case happened in Miami Dade, but the statute applies the same way on the Treasure Coast and everywhere else in Florida. Families here increasingly use known donors, egg donors, and gestational carriers to build their households, and the agreements they sign at the start of that process carry more legal weight than most people realize. A warm relationship between a donor and a child years later does not change what the donor gave up on paper, and a parent’s later wishes, however sincere, do not override a contract that already settled the question.
What this means if you are planning your family or your estate
If you are using a donor, get the agreement in writing before conception and make sure it says plainly who the intended parents are and what rights, if any, the donor keeps. If you already have a donor child and you want that child provided for in your estate, say so directly in your will or trust rather than relying on informal statements, and keep your estate documents consistent with whatever agreement you signed.
This case also carries a warning for anyone heading to an appeals court. When a trial judge rules against you for two separate reasons, you have to challenge both. Leaving one ground alone, even the one that feels less important, can decide the whole case before an appeals court ever reaches the issue you actually wanted argued. This dispute has already been through years of motions and two separate appeals, and the paternity question at the center of it still has not been answered on the merits.
General information, not legal advice. Every case is different.
The Law Offices of Travis R. Walker, P.A.
1100 SE Federal Highway, Stuart, FL 34994
(772) 708 0952
www.TravisWalkerLaw.com








